November 17, 2026 | Issue 178

Amateurs Think Expected Returns, Professionals Think Risk Exposure

Nikolay Stoykov
Managing Partner at Alaric Securities

The end of 2026 is approaching fast. That usually brings all kinds of predictions, or at least requests for predictions – what should a “normal” guy invest in? What should I buy, and what should I avoid? Far fewer ask about their risk exposure.

I don’t mean those are stupid or incorrect questions. I mean they are not the important ones. The most important question is: What is the forward distribution of returns of your portfolio?

Why expected returns get all the attention

Remarkably, even seasoned professionals may have some serious theoretical flaws, lack the knowledge of how to estimate that distribution, or, at the very least, show reluctance to impartially investigate those possibilities.

There is a very good reason for that – equity valuation or finding out the expected return of a portfolio is sexy! Finding out the expected volatility or risk of that portfolio is NOT SEXY, not sexy at all!

Axiom: People make capital allocations based on expected returns. In reality, what they acquire is risk exposure that may eventually materialize as returns or losses.

Expected returns are subjective; risk exposure is measurable

While investors make decisions based on expected portfolio valuations, those valuations are practically always subjective, or at the very least conditional. As such, the expected profitability may or may not materialize. By contrast, the historical volatility of a portfolio is observable, and its [implied volatility can be estimated from market prices](LINK: Options Trading page). In other words, expected returns are subjective, while risk exposure is considerably more measurable – although future risk is never known with certainty.

Example: the risk exposure of buying the dip in SMH

SMH (semiconductor ETF) is down quite a bit from its highs – maybe as much as 30%. An investor may understandably decide to buy the ETF expecting a 30% return.

In reality, this may not happen.

What is actually happening is that the investor is buying  an ETF that has historically exhibited annual volatility of approximately 35%. The options market may price its one-year implied volatility at approximately 40%.

Using those numbers, we can estimate a two-standard-deviation downside scenario for that position. Under a simplified normal-return assumption, and before accounting for expected returns, this corresponds to a loss of approximately 70% (2 × historical volatility) to 80% (2 × implied volatility).

What a two-standard-deviation event means

A two-standard-deviation downside event is approximately a 2.3% lower-tail event, or roughly a 1-in-44 outcome under the normal-distribution assumption. It is not a prediction, nor is it a hard limit on potential losses.

So, you see, a return of 30% is just an expectation – a possibility arising from a position in an asset whose annual returns may fluctuate with a standard deviation of around 35–40%.

It is very realistic that such an asset, given its correction from a recent high, CAN return 30% over some reasonably long time frame. However, it is far from the ONLY possibility.

Based on its historical volatility and the options market, we can derive an illustrative two-standard-deviation downside scenario of approximately 70–80% over 12 months.

This is a possibility that even seasoned professionals often fail to appreciate. However, it is very much possible. It is a statistically meaningful illustration of risk that is frequently discounted. That does not make the risk exposure disappear.

Amateurs think firepower; professionals think logistics

A good analogy is that during wars, amateurs think firepower while professionals think logistics. In trading and investing, amateurs think expected returns while professionals think risk exposure.

How much volatility does a 20–25% return require?

Very often, clients come with expected returns – “I want to make 20–25% a year.”

Unfortunately, even the best portfolio managers in the world, such as Warren Buffett, have historically delivered returns accompanied by substantial volatility. Over long periods, a return-to-volatility ratio around 1:1 is already an impressive achievement.

In reality, many reasonably good portfolios may deliver only 1% of excess return for every 2% of volatility.

As such, a portfolio constructed with the ambition of delivering 20–25% annual returns may require accepting risk exposure of 25% annual volatility or more, depending on its composition and investment strategy.

At 25% annual volatility, a two-standard-deviation downside scenario corresponds to approximately 50 percentage points below the expected annual return. If the expected return is 25%, that implies an illustrative annual outcome of approximately −25%, not −50%.

A loss approaching 50% would represent a more extreme outcome under those assumptions, or could arise from a portfolio with greater volatility.

Yes, investors want that 25% per annum, but the pursuit of such returns can expose them to very substantial losses. Two-standard-deviation downside events are uncommon, but they very much do occur. And actual market losses can be even worse, particularly when returns exhibit fat tails, correlations increase, or liquidity disappears.

Yes, amateurs think expected returns. Professionals think risk exposure.

Disclaimer

The articles, podcasts, and newsletters from Alaric Securities OOD are classified as marketing communications. The views expressed are solely those of the individual authors affiliated with Alaric Securities OOD and do not necessarily reflect the views of the company, its subsidiaries, or affiliates. This content is provided for informational purposes only. It does not constitute investment advice, a recommendation, or a solicitation to buy or sell any security, digital asset (such as cryptocurrency), or other financial instrument. Third-party content is included solely for informational purposes and does not reflect the views of Alaric Securities OOD. All investments involve risk, including the possible loss of principal. Past performance is not indicative of future results. References to third-party companies, logos, or trademarks are used under fair use/fair dealing principles for analysis and commentary.
Stay Ahead with Alaric Securities Newsletters
Traders and investors don't need more information - they need better information. That’s what we deliver!
Daily

Start every trading day with a quick, actionable snapshot of global markets, key earnings, and the biggest movers across US, Europe, and Asia. Get the insight before your first coffee is gone.

Weekly

Step back from the daily noise. Each issue explores market trends, industry shifts, trading opportunities, and exclusive updates — learn what's shaping the markets, not just what's trending online. Ready to get the edge?