Bitcoin vs Gold Comparison: Volatility and Long-Term Returns

When it comes to investing, numbers only tell part of the story. This bitcoin vs gold comparison explores not just returns, but also how volatility and psychology shape investor behavior. To make this easier to understand, let’s begin with something simple and relatable — puppies. Just as the excitement and challenges of owning a dog change over time, so too do the experiences of holding assets like gold or bitcoin.

The Life Expectancy of Dogs and Investor Psychology

Do you know the average life expectancy of a pet dog? According to Wikipedia, most dog breeds live between 10 and 15 years.

But here’s a harder question: What percentage of dog owners get a new dog after their first one dies?

The answer: not many. People form deep emotional bonds with dogs, and their loss is often felt as if it were a family member’s death.

Yet all of this is known before ownership begins. Why do so few seriously weigh the grief against the joy of getting a puppy?

Why We Struggle with Volatility: Recency Bias Explained

The answer lies in human psychology. People often fail to recognize long-term patterns when volatility is involved.

Take gold: if it were compounded at 10% annually without swings, expectations would be stable. But if it jumps 40% in one year, many investors convince themselves a “new paradigm” has begun — even if history says otherwise.

This is known as recency bias: we tend to overweight recent results and overlook long-term averages.

Dog ownership has a similar “volatility.” The first year is joyful, but excitement declines, aging brings challenges, and grief is inevitable. We know this in advance, yet the joy of a puppy makes us forget the eventual pain — until it arrives, like an overdue credit card bill.

Gold as a Store of Value: A Bitcoin vs Gold Comparison

Gold has been a store of value for centuries, averaging about 10% annual return over long periods.

For a deeper statistical look at how those returns stack up against short-term volatility, see our recent article Gold as a Hedge Against Inflation: Reality Check

• Total gold market cap: ~$22 trillion

• Long-term appreciation: ~10% annually

In the bitcoin vs. gold comparison, gold serves as the benchmark for what a mature, non-yielding store of value looks like.

Bitcoin’s Explosive 10-Year Growth in the Bitcoin vs Gold Comparison

Now let’s look at Bitcoin. On 31 July 2015, Bitcoin traded at $281. As of 2 September 2025, Bitcoin is trading at approximately $111,339.

That’s:

• ~39,600% return

• ~75% average annual return

To put it in perspective:

Bitcoin vs Gold Comparison (2015–2025)

Has any other asset produced such explosive returns? Very few in history.

Will Bitcoin Mature Like Gold? A Long-Term Comparison

Bitcoin has been the most exciting “puppy” of the financial world. But like puppies, assets mature.

The question is: what happens when growth slows?

Our belief:

• Bitcoin’s long-term appreciation rate is expected to converge toward gold’s ~10% annual rate (or about 6–8% above inflation).

• Discussing Bitcoin reaching $1 million is unrealistic without gold prices significantly increasing.

• Outperformance may continue for a while, but the extraordinary speed and scale of recent gains are unlikely to repeat.

In short, Bitcoin is maturing.

Lessons from the Bitcoin vs Gold Comparison

Just as dog owners often forget about the eventual grief that comes with adopting a puppy, investors frequently overlook the risks of volatility and recency bias when pursuing high returns.

In this bitcoin vs. gold comparison, we see two very different stories – one of explosive short-term gains and one of steady long-term preservation.

Bitcoin delivered once-in-a-lifetime growth, but its future is likely to resemble gold’s steady 10% annual appreciation rather than repeating 75% yearly gains.

Do you believe bitcoin will remain man’s best “store of value,” or is another paradigm shift coming?

Disclaimer